Acura TSX Forum banner

1 - 20 of 28 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
98 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I'm considering the TSX as a practical commuting car for myself. I like to drive manual transmission cars, but my wife will only drive automatics. She won't be a regular driver, but it still might be useful to give her the option. I have test-driven the auto, but unfortunately none of the local dealers have manuals available for test drives.

One thing I notice is that the manual has much shorter gearing than the auto, so much that the auto gets better EPA gas mileage. Is the mileage difference true in practice as well? What are the cruising RPMs for the manual in 6th at actual highway speeds (i.e., 65-80 mph); does the manual seem high-strung or noisy on the highway because of the short gearing?

Can anyone who has driven both chime in on how big the differences are in performance, and how good the gearbox feels? I'm trying to decide whether I should be practical and get the auto for my wife and the gas mileage, or get the 6MT to make myself happy.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6 Posts
I have a manual transmission tsx and the engine is revving at 3000 rpm at 60 mph. At higer speeds like 80 mph the engine revs to 3500 something like that. The noise is not detectable. It doesn't bother me. The automatics are usually about 2500 and 3000 respectively. It all sounds the same to me, i had a tsx auto loaner so I could compare, no change of sound detectable. All the same sound in my opinion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
47 Posts
I can't answer any of your questions because I have not driven the automatic one. But I'm going to repeat your words: "get the 6MT to make yourself happy".
The fact that my wife can't drive it is an added bonus :D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24 Posts
i'd say get the mt also. your wife,(everyone) should know how to drive standard anyways. especially if you ever travel across the ocean.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
17 Posts
Sporty Xtra,

There are 4 things to know in life...

(1) Typing
(2) Swimming
(3) Riding a Bike
(4) Driving Stick[/B]

Welcome to the Club!

P.S. I have to give up my manual for an automatic too, but the sports shifter is a "compromise"...don't forget your marriage vows "for richer & poorer, in sickness & in health, etc..." :smash:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
634 Posts
The Sporty Xtra said:
I'm trying to decide whether I should be practical and get the auto for my wife and the gas mileage, or get the 6MT to make myself happy.
I haven't driven a 6MT TSX, but as a manual driver myself, I'll tell you, the TSX's 5AT is an extremely good automatic transmission.

My wife does know how to drive a manual, but she doesn't understand why she should have to shift if the car is perfectly capable of it. So since the TSX is her car, we got the autobox.

The TSX's auto shifts are nice and crisp, and it rarely hunts around for the gear it wants. Also, unlike most 3- or 4-spd autos, it doesn't automatically shift all the way up to top gear at part or low throttle. If you accelerate to 25 or 30 mph, say, and crusie there a few seconds, it will stay in 3rd or 4th so you have instant acceleration without a downshift. After you cruise there for a bit it may shift up if you don't give more gas.

It's also fun to drive in "manumatic" mode, but under most circumstances I never bother because the ATX does a great job anticipating the required gear and responds quickly. It's really very pleasant to drive and doesn't interfere with the enjoyment at all.

In all honesty, if you think that your wife might drive tha car or if you could use a few domestic brownie points, I'd strongly consider the autobox.
 
N

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
Stick. Everybody nowadays drives Autos. Go for the full experience especially since the TSX 6 is one of the best I have ever driven.

Remember, there is no MAN in Automatic but there is in MANual : )
 

·
The Voice of Reason
Joined
·
1,481 Posts
Washington, DC?

The Sporty Xtra said:
I'm considering the TSX as a practical commuting car for myself.
I drove down to DC last month, and traffic was about a bazillion times worse than I remembered it was when I last worked down there, which was in the 1980s.

I've driven a stick shift exclusively for the last 22 years and the DC traffic was so bad that I'd actually consider an AT. Problem with the TSX AT is that the motor isn't awfully powerful, the torque curve is really unsuitable for an AT and the performance is marginal even with the 6-speed manual.

Have you considered the Accord V6 EX? With its automatic it's actually a little faster than the TSX 6-speed manual, at least in a straight line.

http://www.vtec.net/articles/view-article?article_id=113992
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,255 Posts
Interesting. I used to commute to Dallas each day and drive around the area. That led me to get an automatic trans car. I enjoyed the car but missed the stick (have had nothing but mt up this point). I went back to the mt and even in the dallas traffic it is not all that bad. However, I don't drive dallas traffic every day anymore. That is the difference :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
48 Posts
nachob said:
Stick. Everybody nowadays drives Autos. Go for the full experience especially since the TSX 6 is one of the best I have ever driven.

Remember, there is no MAN in Automatic but there is in MANual : )
I drove the manual before I bought the automoatic and I can say one thing...the manual is a thing of beauty. I've never seen a manual that shifts as smooth or precise, and I would have bought one if it hadn't been for my bum knee which prohibits using a clutch even though the TSX clutch is one of the best.

I willl testify about the automatic. I shift early and often. It acts more like a manual transmission than any manumatic I've ever seen (and that includes that awful Chrysler...er...Daimler-Chrysler unit--horrible). I decided to take a trip to our capital city on old US Rt. 60. I kept it in 5th gear whenever possible there and back (boring, i know, but I was trying to prove a point). I got 29.8 mpg. The best I had ever done leaving the car in drive was 26.7. OK, not much, but something.

Either way the TSX is the best unknown jewell in the car biz. Manual or automatic, you can't go wrong.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
634 Posts
bob shiftright said:
Problem with the TSX AT is that the motor isn't awfully powerful, the torque curve is really unsuitable for an AT and the performance is marginal even with the 6-speed manual.

Have you considered the Accord V6 EX? With its automatic it's actually a little faster than the TSX 6-speed manual, at least in a straight line.
Honestly, the ATX works fine even with the low torque curve of the 2.4. Unless you're used to driving a monster it will not feel slow. We drove the Accord EX V6 a couple times, almost back-to-back with the TSX, and it wasn't enough quicker to make up for the general lack of enthusiasm it generated. The TSX ATX may give up a little on acceleration but it's a way more fun car to drive than the Accord.
 

·
, Moderator Emeritus
Joined
·
8,663 Posts
Duke said:
Honestly, the ATX works fine even with the low torque curve of the 2.4. Unless you're used to driving a monster it will not feel slow. We drove the Accord EX V6 a couple times, almost back-to-back with the TSX, and it wasn't enough quicker to make up for the general lack of enthusiasm it generated. The TSX ATX may give up a little on acceleration but it's a way more fun car to drive than the Accord.
That's what I felt when driving the AV6... the car also felt "floaty" (suspension) compared to the TSX...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
67 Posts
Go for the stick! If youre payin' for it you pick what car YOU want. Thats what i did...i got mine in stick so that NO ONE can touch it...which is basically everyone i know who drives. i have only 3 friends who know how to drive stick..but i'm not letting them touch it either HAHAHA!

I have tested both MT and AT...the power is there...but it is more fun to drive the MT. when i'm in 6th gear the rpms are at 2500 when doing 80 (which is like 100kph for us Canadians)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
54 Posts
Yeah, the MT is much nicer, but if you live in an area where you are always in traffic, such as SoCal, then thn the AT will come in handy more. Regardless of what you choose, it should be something that you feeling comfortable driving and not what people tell you to get.

-Jimmy
 

·
TSX of the Month Winner
Joined
·
1,199 Posts
Auto! one hand free to talk, eat, shave, lip stick, etc. Its a commute , so just relax and not have to worry about shifting. Just my .02
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9 Posts
Kaidoi said:
P.S. I have to give up my manual for an automatic too, but the sports shifter is a "compromise"...don't forget your marriage vows "for richer & poorer, in sickness & in health, etc..." :smash:

I am right there with you on that boat!!! My beemer was manual and boy do I miss stick shift right about now!!!
 
N

·
Guest
Joined
·
0 Posts
Get the 6 MT. It has the nicest gearbox shifter I have ever driven. Car and Driver named the TSX to their top 10 but if you read the fine print, they raved about the 6 speed. While the auto is nice, it would just be a nice looking Accord. Coupled with the 6 speed, it is much nicer. Make yourself happy. Get an auto when you are in a wheelchair. Good luck.
 
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
Top