Matt King,
Wheel choice is so much personal preference. I just set a budget, went to a local wheel shop and just poured over catalogs picking out several styles, and asked questions (some styles may not come in the size or offset you want). Tire type is also important. I went with performance all-season tires but found that summer tires were much better for grip and being in warm SoCal. For rims I went with some forged Enkei RP03s