Coming from several mechanical manual transmission cars, I can say that moving to the TSX's manual transmission had quite a bit of learning curve. Having to remind myself to make sure that I keep pressure on the throttle so that that it is never fully released during a gear shift sucks...I tend to forget and will sometimes give passengers a jerky ride. DBW implementations on other cars, such as BMWs, are great. Acura got their DBW implementation wrong in the TSX. Anyone who has driven a non-DBW manual transmission car knows that there is something wrong. How many times has there been a thread from a newbie stating his MT-driving experience yet needing instructions on how to drive a TSX smoothly? The answer: way too many...no one should have to re-learn how to drive manual transmission vehicles once they already know how to drive one.
Drivers with automatic transmissions won't see the DBW issue since the computer in those cars handle the gear shifts 100%. With manual transmission, half of the equation is the driver, so if the driver isn't driving like how the manual transmission wants to be driven, there will be issues. In non-DBW vehicles, the manual transmission is stupid and just goes along with the driver. In DBW vehicles, the manual transmission thinks for itself and teaches the driver to shift it the way it wants to be shifted (keeping the gas pedal at 1% rather than fully releasing it).